Linguistic Anthropology

The study of language has been part of anthropology since the discipline started in the 1ate 1870s. This site is a place for linguistic anthropologists to post their work and discuss important events and trends in the field.

Thursday, November 06, 2008

A Campaign of Condescension? You Betcha!

--by Peter Haney

Although the world will remember 2008 Presidential election as a milestone in U.S. race relations, campaign talk was also shot through with open gender conflict and sublimated class conflict, both on the levels of style and content. And in the race between style and content, style won the election handily in volley after volley of half-truths, anecdotes, and competing synecdoches. This was nowhere more noticeable than in the media circus surrounding Republican Vice-Presidential candidate Sarah Palin. During her time in the spotlight, Governor Palin delighted Christian conservatives by combining ideological purity with chirpy, homespun belligerence. These same qualities inspired obsessive hatred in self-professed liberals. For liberal commentators who take pride in their intellectual sophistication, she has been an irresistible foil. For similarly inclined conservatives, she has been an embarrassment. Poll after poll has suggested that after an initial period of infatuation, voters began to doubt her intelligence and qualification for the job of Vice President. The significance of these doubts for the Republican loss in 2008 will be debated endlessly. What is clear is that Gov. Palin exposed the perversity of what passes for populism in U.S. political discourse. The idea that “anybody” could become president is such a powerful cliché in U.S. politics that smart writers devote entire books to refuting it. But Palin inspired even some populists to wonder whether opening up the White House to just anybody was a good idea. All this suggests that her fall from political grace can be seen as a failed example of what the late French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu calls a strategy of condescension.

For Bourdieu, regular readers of this blog will recall, a strategy of condescension occurs when someone at the top of a social hierarchy adopts the speech or style of those at the bottom. With such a move, the dominant actor seeks to profit from the inequality that he or she ostensibly negates. When Anglo politicians, for example, trot out a few words of broken Spanish on the U.S. campaign trail, they hope to benefit from the unspoken rule that political discourse here will occur in English. It is precisely that rule that leads some voters who identify with the Spanish language to see its use as a thoughtful gesture on the politician’s part. Although Palin’s campaign persona represents an extreme example of the strategy of condescension, she was not the only candidate to take such an approach. Vice President Elect Joe Biden’s endless allusions to his childhood in Scranton, Pennsylvania and visits to Home Depot are also textbook examples. Note that for Biden, being an ordinary guy is all about consumption and style rather than labor. When President Elect Barack Obama said in his acceptance speech that the change he represented had been “a long time comin’,” he replaced the nasal consonant represented by “ng” in English spelling with that represented by “n.” In the U.S., this substitution connotes informality and is popularly associated with both White working class and African American vernacular speech. White middle-class liberal friends of mine have criticized Palin for her colloquialism and have expressed longing for a vice president who could, in their words, “prounounce a g.” Most of these friends render “ng” as “n” themselves in unguarded moments, of course, although few of them use her regionally marked nasalized vowels. They key difference here is that my friends believe that Obama can use the formal, standard register of English and that Sarah Palin cannot. I am less convinced of the Governor’s linguistic inflexibility. But it is clear in any case that those who mock her speech see her apparent lack of access to privileged styles as a sign of other, more serious deficiencies.

This is precisely the risk of a strategy of condescension. Bourdieu notes that a dominant actor who symbolically negates hierarchies must do so “without appearing to be ignorant or incapable of satisfying their demands” (1991:69). In her effort to play with hierarchies of linguistic competence, Sarah Palin failed to convince voters that she was above the game. Her attempt to present herself as plain folks failed precisely because people believed it. Joe Biden, by contrast, failed less badly because people, on some level, did not believe him. Another interesting contrast is the case of Senator Hillary Clinton, who was roundly mocked for aping the speech of audiences in the South on the campaign trail. In Clinton’s case, national audiences found her affected drawl so different from her usual speaking style that they doubted its authenticity. Palin inspired no such doubts, but this alone does not explain her failure. Remember that the current occupant of the White House is the scion of an elite New England political family who used language to convince the world that he was a Texas cowboy. His colloquialisms were as forced and robotic as Palin’s, and they succeeded equally well in giving him a common touch with the public. That both Palin and Bush convinced the country of their speech styles’ authenticity is clear from the work of comedians who satirize them. Tina Fey’s overrated Saturday Night Live parody, which recast the Alaska governor as a defanged, rustic ingénue, reinforced rather than questioning Palin’s “Wasilla hillbilly” persona. Similarly, the legion of comedians who lampoon Bush never show him letting the Good Old Boy act lapse while relaxing with Poppy. Belief was not the issue here. But few voters appear to have worried about Bush’s competence or command of policy until after the disastrous consequences of his policies and tactics became clear. These same voters would not give Palin a chance. What explains this difference?

There are many possible reasons for this apparent contradiction. One is sexism. Another is what I would call condescension fatigue. Regarding sexism, we might start by asking why Gov. Palin never found a gender-appropriate term when she described herself as a “Joe Six-Pack.” The likely answer is that whatever good qualities Americans may attribute to working class White masculinity are weaker for working class White femininity. Voters who once elected a President who talked like a guy they could have a beer with may very well have balked at electing a female Vice President whose speech gave the same impression. Joe Six-Pack may have a shot at public office, but his sister Jane? Forget it. Still, it seems unlikely that sexism alone can explain Palin’s downfall. If condescension fatigue is a factor, it may be that the previous administration has run strategies of condescension into the ground. Having seen themselves, their neighbors, and the world hurt by wolfish conservatism in populist sheep’s clothing, voters may very well have responded differently this year to the common touch than they did in 2000 and 2004. Given the perception that incompetence played a role in the failure of the administration’s occupation of Iraq, its neglect of New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina, and its mismanagement of the economy, voters may well have hungered for signs of the intellectual sophistication and technical expertise that most of us do not associate with working class speech. If this is true, it may follow that the Democrats prevailed not because of Biden’s trips to Home Depot but in spite of them. Other factors may also be at work here. One thing, however, is clear. If the candidates’ populist style ends up translating into policies that benefit the majority of Americans, it will be because that majority stands up and demands it. Until then, the only freedom we can expect to enjoy is the free play of elite political speech styles unmoored from any organic links to the interests of the electorate.


Bourdieu, Pierre. 1991. "Price Formation and the Anticipation of Profits." In John Thompson, Gino Raymond, and Matthew Adamson, Eds. and Trans. Language and Symbolic Power. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, pp. 66-90.


Blogger Pamthropologist said...

Wonderful post. I, particularly appreciate how "usable" this piece is for teaching students in an intro class.

I wonder a bit about the "McCain affect". Did his own, occasional (well, frequent) stumbling incoherency, play into our doubts about the intellectual capabilities of the ticket?

11:43 AM  
Blogger CarlD said...

Way cool. However, I don't agree with the premise that Palin fell down. She was chosen to consolidate the social conservative base, primarily rural voters who were deeply suspicious of McCain's history of bipartisanship and votes against veterans' benefits. And if you look at the map, that's exactly who ended up going strong for the ticket; so she seems to have delivered.

The uncanny thing for us eggheads to wrap our brains around is that to her constituency, Palin never stopped looking like a breath of fresh air, an archetypical bearer of matriarchal/amazon values perhaps, a 'real woman'. She was also a 'maverick', all of which meant that her appeal was and remained common sense, not wonky policy competence. Our doubts about the intellectual capabilities of the ticket are no doubt fightin' words to the 20-30% of voters who would rather gargle with Drano than vote for a slick intellectual.

Back to Bourdieu, I'm wondering if the condescension argument only works for those fractions of the dominated class whose 'cultural goodwill' is motivated by upward trajectory and projective identification with their betters.

12:15 AM  
Blogger John said...

Two questions: (1) Is the condescension model accurate for a situation in which a candidate is attempting to demonstrate both that they are "one of us" and also highly qualified, i.e., very smart, experienced or both? I think of both Bill Clinton and Barack Obama, whose task has been more to show that they have not forgotten where they came from than to humanize a pre-existing high status. (2) Are you not underestimating the importance of material context? 

Here I think of Joe Biden, whose references to his birth in Scranton, etc., were reinforced by (a) his daily commute back to Delaware, initially to take care of his sons after the deaths of his wife and daughter and (b) his being by far the least wealthy member of the Senate. In a very real sense, he wasn't just telling a story; he was living it. Conversely, what did in Sarah Palin was not just what she said or how she said it, but her real ignorance and, then, the Neiman-Marcus shopping spree.

9:07 AM  
Blogger John said...

Continuing the line that carl has opened with his "upward trajectory" and "projective identification." We start with a hierarchy in which the superior adopts the inferior's speech style to assert a commonality. But is this always condescension? To me condescension implies that the hierarchy is a given, and the superior's position is secure. This is precisely not the case in a (small-d) democratic election where the candidate presents himself as one of the people. Here the danger is being perceived as someone who has abandoned his roots and the shift in style evidence that the candidate has not forgotten who he or she is. Similar mechanism but different implication.

12:59 AM  
Blogger dogscratcher said...

Perhaps not condescension fatigue, but might the "contradiction" simply be a knee jerk reaction to having been recently (for the last eight years) hosed by a similarly homey talking politician?

12:08 AM  
Blogger peterme said...

"A long time comin'" is very likely a reference to Sam Cooke's civil rights-era song, "A Change is Gonna Come"

I don't think this is an example of condescension on Obama's part, as much of an acknowledgment of the movement of which he is part.

2:41 PM  
Blogger rscredits said...

Hey , what you say is really informative and funny, i like it and hope for more runescape gold

I think you just did a right thing to make this choice, rs gold you know that's really funny and i am sure you will not regret.One half of the world does not know how the other half lives

runescape gold

12:16 AM  
Blogger Richard Ressinger said...

Whoa 2008 election feels so much like 2016, just with roles reversed!

8:50 AM  
Blogger peter x said...

osrs gold

Hey , what you say is really informative and funny, i like it and hope for more RuneScape gold

I think you just did a right thing to make this choice, rs gold you know that's really funny and i am sure you will not regret reddit discuss. One half of the world does not know how the other half lives

osrs gold
old school runescape gold
rs 2007 gold
07 runescape gold
rs gold for sale
cheapest runescape gold
runescape gold for sale
sell rs3 gold
buy osrs gold
buy osrs account
cheapest runescape 07 gold

12:37 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Thank you for sharing this also check for RS gold

3:32 PM  
Blogger Danny said...

Thank you for the article on you can get the recruitment form at Npower News and Also get Immigration Recruitment latest job news from there. Do you know that airforce mil ng Nigerian Airforce Recruitment form is now available online. See details on JAMB Form

5:07 PM  
Blogger Cadencealida said...

Really great sharing, thank you. is an online store mainly engaged in the business related to the Path of Exile.
POE Currency
POE Exalted Orb
POE Chaos Orb
POE Items

ps4, Xbox, pc all available

3:19 AM  
Blogger Jenna said...

It is much fun for entertaining a baby. The best baby

activity center for 1 year old
is one of best ways to entertain you baby.

There are a lot of items for them to do things that play music, spin and many

light colors. There are some activity center even with a mat for your lovely

baby to enjoy the fun tummy time and learning to crawl, and a saucer for them

to have dance or jumpy time. It can even manage to give you time to load the

dishwasher or fold laundry or work on your laptop or even relax!

For more interesting and useful information, please visit our parenting blog


9:01 PM  
Blogger jobspuls said...

Thank you for the article on you can get the recruitment form at Npower News and Also get Immigration Recruitment latest job news from there. Do you know that airforce mil ng Nigerian Airforce Recruitment form is now available online. See details on AMB FormJ

2:58 AM  
Blogger judo said...

Every working mom strives consistently to balance between work and parenting. But you can find work from home jobs data entry

12:05 PM  
Blogger judo said...

Does the pump come with special features to facilitate pumpin? Find more about it with the new camon 15 device

12:07 PM  
Blogger smrtsmith said...

When you Madden NFL 20 Coins on MMOB2C, the fastest time is five minutes after placing the order Can be received within.

2:50 AM  
Blogger smrtsmith said...

After placing the order DFO Gold, you can also receive the goods in time. It is particularly worth mentioning that there is a very interesting lottery carousel on this website, the discount amount varies, depending on your luck.

When you Buy OSRS Gold on, we will stop real-time quotation to satisfy you at the best price.

2:55 AM  
Blogger Last born said...

Thanks for sharing this amazing post with us uniben school fees

6:16 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Thanks for the article Ghana Recruitment

4:17 PM  
Blogger Cadencealida said...

Animal Crossing: New Horizons is currently the hottest casual game.

Want to enjoy the best leisure life, ACBellsBuy liberate your time, this is a mature choice, more efficient. It is also more suitable for players who do not have enough time.

3:39 AM  
Blogger ghjkwl said...

Linguistics is my field of study. Thanks for sharing this wonderful article.Ghana Recruitment, Police Recruitment

7:32 AM  
Blogger ghjkwl said...

I really appreciate this content.Latest School News, Neco Result
Jamb Result
Jamb Form

7:34 AM  
Blogger EDDY said...

I sincerely appreciate this post from Education Today

8:54 AM  
Blogger Spicy said...

The bio on Omah Lay and Josh2funny was timely, and you presented the details in a way that everyone could enjoy. - Jahkhin

12:11 PM  
Blogger FlashGeek said...

This article needs a lot of paragraphs Myschoolbeam

1:57 AM  
Blogger Frank said...

Thanks for sharing this information Mini itx pc

1:42 AM  
Blogger ghjkwl said...

Thanks Nigeria Airforce Recruitment

5:35 PM  
Blogger Studydriller said...

Thanks for making out time to provide this information. Apply for job recruitment in Nigeria via Also, Check for shortlisted candidates such as the Nigerian Navy Shortlisted Candidates 2021.

7:18 PM  
Blogger Studydriller said...

ANother good one from you, very well written and quite information, those i still have some suggestion PastquestionPDF Published the latest information on school of nursing form such as UCH Ibadan Nursing Form

2:29 PM  
Blogger Anonymous said...
Ibom Air Recruitment 2021
Nigerian Breweries Recruitment
TRCN List of Shortlisted Candidates
TRCN Past Questions and Answers
Rivers SUBEB Screening Date

11:57 AM  
Blogger Ruby said...

Check out this pdf shortlist NSCDC

12:20 AM  
Blogger Goodtime said...

Great and amazing post
checkout this

3:11 AM  
Blogger Essien said...

Nice updates from you guys. I sincerely appreciate this effort, and I'm still looking forward to hear more from this weblog. Thanks always updating this particular page. Npower News

8:16 AM  
Blogger Goodtime said...

Thanks for sharing this amazing post JAMB Form

12:15 PM  
Blogger zarkazijar said...

A million appreciation to you for sharing this perfect article. After reading this I found it extremely enlightening and informative. Thank you. Need information on current scholarship programs, click on scholarship

6:30 AM  
Blogger Essien said...

Its nice and educative blog for one to come around always. I'm happy for arriving at this particular blog. This article worthy surfing through. Thanks for sharing your beautiful knowledge. CLICK HERE FOR MORE INFO.- futminna post utme past question

9:29 AM  
Blogger Godwin Ibanga said...

You can Check Nigerian Police Shortlisted Candidates Here
FRSC Shortlisted Candidates

5:01 AM  
Blogger Emmanuel Essien said...

So many informative things are provided here,I really happy to read this post,I was just imagine about it and you provided me the correct information I really bookmark it,for.
Nigerian Police Shortlisted Names
NIMC Recruitment
Nigerian Army Login Portal
Big Brother Naija Application Form
Lagos State Teachers Shortlisted Candidates
First Bank Recruitment
Nigerian Air Force List of Shortlisted Candidates

6:22 PM  
Blogger Automix said...

Thanks for sharing this is great update with us i will always check back here more info

10:33 AM  
Blogger Mahil mithu said...

Very interesting post and thanks for your knowledgeable sharing with us. Keep doing well!
Virginia Military Divorce
Woman Divorce Lawyers Near Me
Fairfax Divorce Attorney

6:11 AM  
Blogger Hashini said...

Nice post! it was too good and thank you for sharing it.
pvc foam board manufacturers in kerala
pvc foam board manufacturers kerala

10:59 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home