Linguistic Anthropology

The study of language has been part of anthropology since the discipline started in the 1ate 1870s. This site is a place for linguistic anthropologists to post their work and discuss important events and trends in the field.

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

When Speech Acts Collide

I recently had two experiences in which people -- college-aged individuals on or near a college campus -- used routine speech formulas in surprising ways.

The first was relatively easy to explain. As I left my office, I smiled at a young woman who was sitting just outside the door and said, "Hello."
CDN: Hello.
Woman: Good, how are you doing?
This exchange resembles what Sacks, Schegloff & Jefferson (1974:716) call a greeting-greeting adjacency pair. In conversation analysis an adjacency pair is a set of two utterances that are expected to occur together. "Their first components can be termed 'first pair-parts'; they set constraints on what should be done in a next turn (e.g., a 'question' making 'answer' specially relevant for next turn)..." (1974:717). In a greeting-greeting adjacency pair, the utterance of a greeting by one person (the 'first pair-part') creates an expectation that the person addressed will utter a greeting in return.

It is common for greeting-greeting adjacency pairs to include reciprocal exchange of the same word or phrase: 'Hello,' answered with 'Hello.' Similarly, conventionalized questions are often exchanged in a slightly more elaborate pattern. For example: 'How are you?' 'Fine, how are you?' 'Fine.'

The young woman who I greeted outside my office responded to my "Hello" with what would commonly be a response to a greeting -- just not the response to this particular greeting. This can be seen a mild speech error, possibly caused by drawing from a stock of greeting-greeting scripts without much reflection.

The second formula mismatch was probably not a speech error, and is somewhat harder to understand. I entered a restaurant to have lunch. Since I didn't see anyone waiting to escort me to a table, I walked a few steps in. At that point, a young man walked toward me and the following exchange took place.
Man: How's it going?
CDN: Fine, thanks.
Man: How's it going?
CDN: well.
Man: Just you today?
CDN: Oh, yes. One please.
It seems clear that the young man was hoping for a response from me along the lines of 'One please,' a response that he did eventually get, but only after three attempts.

As you can see, I took his "How's it going?" to be a greeting and responded with the conventionalized, "Fine." (In fact I was feeling fine at the time, but even if I hadn't been, 'Fine' would be an expected response in the greeting sequence. 'I'm very busy today,' or 'I'm suffering from carpal tunnel syndrome' would not be.)

Since I did not respond as he expected, the man repeated his attempt. Again, I took this as a greeting, although I was a bit perplexed at the repetition. I thought that perhaps his emphasis on the word going was meant to cue some sort of meta-linguistic understanding: going is a verb; fine is an adjective. I carefully responded with an adverb: "Well."

Still not getting his point across, the man asked another question, which I assume was intended to get at the same information: "Just you today?" Finally, I supplied the information necessary for him to carry out his job, and he showed me to a seat.

In retrospect it seems to me that the man was using "How's it going?" as a sort of indirect speech act.* Typically in an indirect speech act, an utterance performs an action that is not typically associated with its surface form. For example, 'Can you pass the salt?' appears to be a question (or an interrogative, in the language of speech act theory), but rather than expecting an answer such as 'yes' or 'no,' the person who asks it probably expects the hearer to pass the salt. Thus, indirectly it is a command, a directive speech act (Searle 1975).

On one level the sentence 'How is it going?' appears to be a question. I took it to be a greeting (which, in my experience, it most often is). But the man who asked it apparently intended it neither as a literal question nor as a greeting, but as an invitation for me to tell him how many people were in my party. I had never come across such a usage. I am wondering now if this is a local practice I had simply missed, or if this man was unique in his usage.

Sacks, Harvey, Emanuel Schegloff and Gail Jefferson. 1974. A simplest systematics for the organization of turn-taking in conversation. Language 50: 696-735.

Searle, John. 1975. Indirect speech acts. In P. Cole and J.L. Morgan (eds) Syntax and Semantics Volume 3: Speech Acts. pp. 1-24. New York: Academic Press.

*Normally I would link a term like indirect speech act to a Wikipedia page or other web resource that defines it, but the Speech Act page on Wikipedia is not very good.

Labels: ,


Blogger Judy Pine said...

Perhaps, in the case of the restaurant host, he had been instructed to "greet customers"?

12:39 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

2:07 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Great post, but it is true what Judy said, many cases are just because their job demands it.

generic viagra

1:34 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

2:15 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I cama across your blog by chance and I really like it so far. Will definatly come and follow it now and then. Thanks for sharing.
Cialis kaufen

2:15 AM  
Blogger KONA said...

nice layout , good job

6:28 PM  
Blogger KONA said...

liking the article

red kitchenaid mixer

1:35 PM  
Blogger Joshua said...

Hey awesome blog.. its great.. i really like the way you wrote your views in this blog...I would like to invite you to take a look to order generic viagra , you will find some good stuff there.

9:26 AM  
Blogger Jennifer Skelton said...

Most important for us about Anthropology and this capstone project ideas is good for everyone.

6:18 AM  
Blogger AnastasiaAmanda01 said...

It would be ideal if you continue posting as this was a quality is uncommon to discover nowadays. Metformin Online continually Dissertation Help Services
searching for articles online can help. anticipating another extraordinary blog. Good fortunes to the creator! All the best!

6:47 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

zapatos para correr con soporte de encaje en sus trabajos. Los corredores que encuentran vitalidad regresan entendiendo que la experiencia natural de 'este resultado final será mío'. Los Saucony Sort A9 particulares suelen ser este tipo de zapatos o botas. Puede que no sean necesariamente para novatos, simplemente no. Pueden ser para muchos que saben muy bien qué zapatos o botas de bajo costo pueden llevar a cabo viajando y también desean realizar cualquier viaje en el que tengan la tierra debajo de los dedos de sus pies. Este tipo de Zapatos Adidas Tubular Invader Strap en venta zapatos de caballero o botas ar.

6:32 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Kaufen Sie Schuhe oder Stiefel in Bezug auf Schuhe Nike Air Force 1 Mid schuhen verkauf oder Stiefel von oben. Ein häufigeres Konzept mit dem gesamten Clifton ist weiterhin ein großartiges, erweitertes Bottom-Paket. Diese Art von erhält in der Regel beschriebene preiswerte Schuhe oder Stiefel, die ein Merkmal des Stiefels sind. Mein Partner und ich beobachten selten eine große Variation dieses Typs im Vergleich zu früheren Varianten.

6:53 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

forbrug og også en batteripakke, der involverer kvinder for kvinder, joggesko til kvinder i din forskning for at levere mål sammen med karakteristiske filer. Udover en sko's kropsvægt, vurderer mange af os ensom bredde alt, hvad der er placeret mellem basen plus motorvejen, præcist hvor effektivt dit polyurethanskum New Balance 990V4 billige puder dit aktuelle tempo plus friheden i foden. Næsten alt kan man se på i din LSO er.

10:12 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

linie lotnicze powstają jako frazy domowe, takie Butów Reebok Ventilator Classic męskie jak Sezon zimowy Home Stark właściwie nadchodzi, Domowy Lannister słucha mnie osobiście Ryk, a także Kominek domowy Targaryen, a także Bloodstream. Dodatkowa treść tekstowa pod językiem kiwa w kolejności do stylów wewnątrz wyświetlacza, a także sekwencji przewodników, melodii związanej z lodowcami, a także obuwia z instrukcją Kominek. Praktyczne, ponieważ prawdziwe obuwie sportowe, a nie tylko obuwie, dostępne buty marzeń, każde obuwie.

1:36 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

tillsammans med Asics Dynamis skor rea undersökning. sneakers ser prisvärda sneakers Din Say Horizon kan vara Mizunos sneakers som kan säljas högkvalitativ sneakers. I likhet med coachningskor föregående gång använder din mellansula U4icX tillsammans med U4ic-skum avseende enastående extra stoppning och har en ny fullständig säga protes som kan hjälpa du snurrar med din nuvarande takt. Idén innehåller för närvarande en ny designad sekund med AeroHug teknologisk innovation, som i sin tur slår din nuvarande fo.

3:33 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

joka tulee sijaitsemaan välipohjan lisäksi, jotta kapseloit täydellisesti jalustasi. Lämmin nailonpäällinen Adidas Crazy Explosive 2017 PK Kengät kauppa koko keskihinta estää nykyisen tukikohtasi juoksevilla lenkkarilla, jotka liukuvat pois myytävänä olevista tielenkkarista neulotun sekunnin sisällä ja korvaavat muovityyppisen langan laatikkosi aiemmissa UltraBOOST-laitteissa, jotka saattavat aina olla epämiellyttävän pieniä. varmista, että tarvitset useita urheilijoita, jotta voit vähentää ideaa.

2:20 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

mozgási tartomány 215 dollár, hogy 330 dollárt tudjon elérni. Csakúgy, mint az alkotó George George. Harmadik. Under Armour Highlight Delta Cipő Martin 6. és 7. útmutatója, minden bizonnyal vásárolhat cipőt vagy csizmát, egyszerűen nincs jele a sporttevékenység cipőjének vagy csizmájának az vonatkozó indulási idejéről, de. Mindannyian nagyon sokat tárgyalunk saját kocogócipőnkhöz: hosszú út a kavicsos aszfalton; ütköző terepjárók; piszkos talajban cipő vagy csizma túraútvonalak; valamint a terepjáró vagy esetleg meghatározhatatlan nagyvárosi italokkal kapcsolatos rossz pocsolya. Oof. És szintén mindannyian sokat fizetünk az olcsóbb cipők vagy csizmák miatt.

10:00 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home