Linguistic Anthropology

The study of language has been part of anthropology since the discipline started in the 1ate 1870s. This site is a place for linguistic anthropologists to post their work and discuss important events and trends in the field.

Tuesday, July 21, 2009

Who speaks Shoshone, and when?

A comment on last Sunday's Weekend Edition radio program inspired me to think about two questions. A participant in the Shoshone/Goshute Youth Language Apprenticeship Program (SYLAP) commented:

Someone will step in. You can even bring in a white man to [run a business]. But there isn't going to be a white man who can speak your language.

I wrote about the first of my two questions on Sunday. (What is a "white man"?) Today I'd like to think more about questions of identity and language, particularly in terms of language preservation and revitalization.

Let me preface this by saying that I applaud SYLAP and programs like it. Native American languages are disappearing at an alarming rate. Even those that are not already disappearing because they are not being acquired by young children are shrinking year after year. I in no way mean to downplay the value of the work being done by apprenticeship programs or other projects that help get more young people interested in learning and using Native American languages.

Furthermore, I applaud the young woman who made the comment I quoted above. I am happy and excited to see intelligent young people seeking out ways to serve their communities and the world around them. And every smart and dedicated person coming into a linguistics program is a cause for celebration in my book.

Still, I would like to unpack the notion that "there isn't going to be a white man who can speak your language." I'm going to suggest that such ideas might do as much harm as good to the cause of language preservation. And a good portion of the blame for such thinking may be due to linguistic anthropology, though other fields and practices share in the culpability.

From its earliest days, linguistic anthropology explored the links between the cultural practices of various groups of people and the forms of language that they use. Let me note the differences between early twentieth century views of language and culture in anthropology and those of nineteenth century philosophers such as Herder and von Humboldt. Where the philosophers saw language and culture as essentially and indissolubly linked, the anthropologists suggested merely that, "In the main they [language and culture] have grown up together, constantly influencing each other" (Whorf 1941). In terms of their effect on contemporary thought, this may be a distinction without a difference. The idea that each language reflects a unique worldview, which in turn effects culture, is probably associated more with the linguists Sapir and Whorf than with any other individuals.

A problem for languages like Shoshone, Mohawk, or Lakota - not to mention Corsican, Ainu, Paiwan or literally thousand of others around the world - is that they are not associated with a nation-state. Shoshone is a nationality, but most Shoshone people are citizens of the United States. The idea that it is "natural" for all Americans to speak English (often only English), as well as efforts by the US government during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries to suppress indigenous languages, have pushed the language to endangered status. It is estimated that perhaps no more than 3,000 people in the entire world speak Shoshone today.

In this marginalized state, many endangered languages continue to exist in specialized "culture" realms. I know very little about contemporary Shoshone cultural practices (Don't let my confident writing style fool you), but in ethnic and linguistic minority communities I do know, people often talk about "our culture" as something distinct from everyday life. In these cases "our language" is too often thought of as something separate from our lives.

Language is an important part of the culture of any community. It is not mistaken or wrong to think of the language practices shared within the group as a special, or in some sense even a sacred part of culture and community life. But by treating language as distinct from other aspects of daily life, don't we promote the idea that it is a specialized activity to be pursued by those with the leisure and the inclination to do so?

I don't have a solution. I don't know how we can come to think of communication in many languages, vitally including Native American languages, as an everyday part of life. But I can't help but think that if somehow we could get all Americans to think of multilingualism as an ordinary part of life, and of Shoshone as an everyday language in Shoshone communities, then preserving the language might be a little easier. And we might even find it unremarkable if a white man who moved in, say to run a business, would learn Shoshone, too.

Labels: , , ,


Blogger Liz said...

Very good point: "if we could get all Americans to think of multilingualism as an ordinary part of life!"

10:08 PM  
Blogger Tim said...

You may be interested to check out and look at my postings on Cherokee and on endangered alphabets. A fuller article is in the works, and I'll let you know more when it comes out, but I think you'll find the photos alone interesting.

1:26 PM  
Blogger Natty Matty said...

Without visiting the taxed question of what it means, I'd question the assertion that Shoshone is not associated with a nation-state. Many of its speakers are indeed associated with legally distinct, sovereign political entities, namely the several Shoshone tribes. All enrolled Indians are dual citizens, of their tribe and of the US. (In 1924 Congress mandated that all American Indians be made US citizens). The great attrition in indigenous languages in the US likely owes more to the ongoing (and perpetually overlooked) colonial nature of federal-Indian relations. The issue isn't what languages may be spoken, but whose lives get to be lived. Thanks for the great blog.

2:07 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

8:30 AM  
Blogger bnjohn said...

I think that English is enough for people who can speak English However another language is always something good!

8:08 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

The subject isn't what verbal message may be verbal, but whose lives get to be live. gratitude for the huge blog college paper help......

5:48 AM  
Blogger said...

It is supposed that perhaps no more than 3,000 people in the entire world speak Shoshone today. The number is too small... Maybe our professional paper writers will be of any academic use!

7:51 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

We at Expertsmind have come up with an Excellent and Probably the most effective amenities of management online tutoring. This certain service allows you to connect with our very capable management specialists and Cara Menyembuhkan Psoriasis Secara Alami.

9:46 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Developed by Brendan Eich, it is a scripting language which allows to hold variety of helpful Procedure like making cookies, making use of visual effect, correcting layout challenges, improvement of interfaces and several much more. Visit :
Walatra Sehat Sendi
Walatra Sehat Sendi
Walatra Sehat Sendi

1:38 AM  
Blogger Mindvalley said...

I just have to thank you, because it’s very difficult to find valuable information like your blog today, thank you very much. ‎

3:44 AM  
Blogger hrroman said...

If you are looking for the Software Engineering Help assignment then in this case you can opt for our Essay Writing.we provide the best Essay Writing Services.We also provideCustom Essay Help for students across the globe. for more information contact us +16692714848.

4:36 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Quickbooks Customer Service Number

8:05 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

11:27 AM  
Blogger Morgan Shaw said...

This was such an uplifting and positive post! Your discussion of the power of gratitude was so inspiring. I loved your suggestions for gratitude practices and can't wait to try them out. Your enthusiasm for mindfulness and positive thinking is contagious. Thank you for spreading so much joy!
I have my specialization in the field of Assignment Help, please visit us to know more.

5:39 AM  
Blogger Home Service Australia said...

Plumber Flemington is a trusted and reliable plumbing service provider in Flemington, Victoria. With years of experience in the industry, they have built a reputation for delivering high-quality plumbing services to both residential and commercial clients. They have a team of licensed and insured plumbers who are highly skilled and knowledgeable in all aspects of plumbing.

Their services include general plumbing, gas fitting, hot water installation melbourne and repair, blocked drains, burst pipes, and emergency plumbing services. They use state-of-the-art equipment and techniques to provide efficient and effective plumbing solutions to their clients.

At Plumber Flemington, they understand the importance of customer satisfaction, and they strive to exceed their clients' expectations with every job they undertake. They offer transparent pricing and upfront quotes, so clients know exactly what they are paying for before any work begins.

Whether you have a small plumbing issue or a major plumbing emergency, Plumber Flemington is the team to call for fast, reliable, and affordable plumbing services.

9:43 PM  
Blogger demon said...

First of all thank you for sharing this article with us. Its really nice how you address the topic and describe that very nicely. I am an online exam help provider. Our team of experienced professionals understands the challenges students face during exam periods. Whether it's understanding complex concepts, managing time effectively, or dealing with exam anxiety, we are here to help Don't let stress hold you back, trust for all your assignment needs! We also provide programming assignment help

8:05 AM  
Blogger jhon carry said...

Thank you for sharing this informative blog with us. Your blog is very useful for us. Are you an aspiring engineer looking to kickstart your career in Australia? Look no further than our top-notch cdr writing services in Australia. Our expert team of writers is here to guide you through the complex process of preparing your CDR, ensuring that you stand out in the competitive world of engineering immigration.

10:32 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home